Different Therapeutic Approaches
Introduction
Panic attacks, characterised by sudden surges of intense fear accompanied by somatic and cognitive symptoms, affect approximately 23-28% of individuals during their lifetime (Craske & Stein, 2021). These episodes, defined by the abrupt onset of palpitations, sweating, trembling, chest discomfort, and catastrophic cognitions, may occur within the context of various anxiety disorders or as isolated phenomena. It has been established that panic attacks significantly impair functioning and quality of life, with numerous individuals developing anticipatory anxiety and avoidance behaviours following initial episodes (Taylor et al., 2020). The treatment of panic attacks has been approached from multiple therapeutic paradigms, each offering distinct conceptualisations and interventions. This article examines how practitioners from varying therapeutic orientations—Rogerian counsellors, family therapists, Gordian therapists, traditional hypnotherapists, cognitive hypnotherapists, and psychotherapists—address panic attacks, with particular attention being paid to the theoretical underpinnings, clinical applications, and empirical support for each methodology. The analysis is framed within the context of cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT), strategic therapy, Gordian therapy (GT), dialectical therapy, and acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) approaches.
Theoretical Conceptualisations of Panic
Person-Centred Understanding
From a Rogerian perspective, panic attacks may be conceptualised as manifestations of incongruence between the self-concept and experience (Mearns & Thorne, 2022). It has been observed that individuals experiencing panic often demonstrate conditions of worth related to perfectionism and control, wherein the physiological experiences of anxiety are interpreted as threatening to the self-structure. The person-centred approach emphasises the therapeutic relationship as the primary mechanism through which psychological flexibility may be developed, allowing for greater acceptance of panic-related sensations without threat to the self.
Systemic Perspectives
Family therapists conceptualise panic attacks within relational dynamics, wherein anxious symptomatology may serve functions within the family system (Stratton, 2019). It has been documented that family responses to panic can inadvertently reinforce symptomatology through processes of accommodation and emotional escalation. Strategic therapy within family systems approaches targets these patterns through interventions designed to disrupt maintaining cycles and establish new relational patterns around anxiety.
Gordian Model
Within the Gordian framework developed by Young (2008), panic is understood to be maintained by catastrophic misinterpretations of bodily sensations and, crucially, by cognitive beliefs about the significance, danger, and uncontrollability of worry about panic. The ‘cognitive attentional syndrome’ (CAS), comprising worry, rumination, threat monitoring, and counterproductive safety behaviours, is identified as the key maintaining factor. Treatment from this perspective aims to modify cognitions about worry rather than the content of panic-related thoughts.
Hypnotherapeutic Conceptualisations
Traditional hypnotherapy approaches panic attacks through accessing altered states of consciousness in which physiological relaxation and new learning may be facilitated. It has been postulated that hypnotic trance enables access to unconscious processes that maintain anxiety, allowing for therapeutic suggestion to be implemented at a deeper level (Hammond, 2020). Strategic hypnotherapy integrates hypnotic techniques with cognitive-behavioural principles, targeting both conscious cognitions and unconscious processes that maintain panic (Alladin, 2016).
Psychodynamic Understanding
Psychodynamic approaches conceptualise panic as potentially rooted in unresolved conflicts, developmental traumas, and unconscious processes (Busch et al., 2019). It has been suggested that panic may represent a displacement of anxiety from interpersonal conflicts onto somatic symptoms, with treatment focusing on insight development and emotional processing.
Therapeutic Approaches and Clinical Applications
Person-Centred Therapy and ACT Integration
Rogerian counsellors treating panic create a therapeutic environment characterised by empathy, unconditional positive regard, and congruence. Through this relationship, clients may experience the acceptance of panic sensations that contradicts catastrophic interpretations. The parallels between this approach and ACT are evident in the emphasis on acceptance processes, though ACT more explicitly targets experiential avoidance through structured interventions.
A clinical example might involve a client who experiences panic attacks while driving. The Rogerian counsellor might provide a non-judgmental space wherein the client’s fear is accepted without condition, gradually enabling the development of psychological flexibility around panic sensations. It has been documented that this non-directive approach facilitates the client’s discovery of their own resources for managing panic (Watson & Kalogivaki, 2020).
Family Therapy and Strategic Interventions
Family therapists address panic by intervening in systemic patterns that maintain symptomatology. It may be observed that in some family systems, panic attacks elicit significant attention and care, inadvertently reinforcing the symptom through operant conditioning processes. Strategic interventions might include prescribing the symptom paradoxically, thereby disrupting anxiety-maintaining patterns.
For instance, in a case where parental responses intensify a teenager’s panic through excessive reassurance and accommodation, the therapist might instruct parents to respond differently, encouraging self-efficacy rather than dependence. Evidence suggests that family-based treatments for panic demonstrate efficacy, particularly when systemic patterns are identified and modified effectively (Lebowitz et al., 2023).
Gordian Therapy and Attentional Processes
Gordian therapy targets the processes that maintain panic rather than the content of panic-related thoughts. Young’s’ Gordian model positions beliefs about the uncontrollability and danger of worry as central to the maintenance of panic disorder. Treatment involves techniques such as attention training and detached mindfulness, which have demonstrated significant efficacy in reducing panic symptoms.
A therapist employing this approach might work with a client who experiences recurrent panic attacks due to beliefs that thinking about panic will cause a heart attack. The client would be guided to practice detached mindfulness, observing panic-related thoughts without engagement, thereby weakening the cognitive beliefs that sustain the panic cycle.
Hypnotherapy and Physiological Regulation
In traditional hypnotherapy, panic treatment often involves inducing a trance state wherein suggestions for physiological regulation and emotional control are administered. It has been established that hypnotic phenomena such as time distortion and dissociation can be harnessed therapeutically for anxiety management (Yapko, 2018).
Strategic hypnotherapy integrates cognitive restructuring with hypnotic techniques. Research by Alladin (2016) indicates that this integration may be particularly effective for panic disorder, as it addresses both explicit catastrophic cognitions and implicit processes. A clinical application might involve hypnotically assisted cognitive restructuring, wherein access to a relaxed state facilitates the integration of more adaptive interpretations of bodily sensations.
Psychodynamic Approaches and Dialectical Integration
Psychodynamic therapy for panic often explores early experiences of vulnerability and loss of control. Busch et al. (2019) have documented the efficacy of this approach, particularly when treatment is of sufficient duration to address characterological aspects of anxiety. Elements of dialectical behaviour therapy may be integrated into treatment, particularly the balance between acceptance and change strategies.
A clinical example might involve a client whose panic attacks began following a significant loss. The therapeutic work would involve exploring unconscious meanings attached to the loss while simultaneously developing concrete skills for emotional regulation, reflecting the dialectical stance of acceptance and change.
Integrative Considerations and Evidence Base
The comparative efficacy of these therapeutic approaches has been the subject of extensive research. It has been established through meta-analyses that whilst CBT has the most substantial evidence base for panic treatment, other approaches demonstrate promising results, particularly when tailored to individual client presentations (Carpenter et al., 2022).
It may be observed that common factors across effective treatments include: (1) addressing avoidance behaviours, (2) modifying catastrophic interpretations of bodily sensations (whether through direct cognitive restructuring or cognitive awareness), and (3) developing skills for physiological regulation.
Conclusion
The treatment of panic attacks across different therapeutic orientations reveals both distinctive methodologies and underlying commonalities. It has been observed that Rogerian counselling provides a foundation of acceptance that contradicts catastrophic interpretations; family therapy addresses systemic patterns that maintain panic; Gordian therapy targets the cognitive processes underlying anxiety; hypnotherapy accesses resources for physiological regulation; and psychodynamic approaches explore developmental origins of panic vulnerabilities.
The integration of these perspectives, informed by evidence-based practices such as CBT, strategic therapy, GT, dialectical therapy, and ACT, offers a comprehensive framework for addressing the multifaceted nature of panic. Future research might beneficially explore the comparative efficacy of these approaches for specific panic presentations, as well as the potential for integrative models that synthesise their strengths.
References
Alladin, A. (2016). Cognitive hypnotherapy for accessing and healing emotional injuries for anxiety disorders. American Journal of Clinical Hypnosis, 59(1), 24-46.
Busch, F. N., Milrod, B. L., Singer, M. B., & Aronson, A. C. (2019). Panic-focused psychodynamic psychotherapy: Extended range psychoanalytic inquiry. Routledge.
Carpenter, J. K., Andrews, L. A., Witcraft, S. M., Powers, M. B., Smits, J. A. J., & Hofmann, S. G. (2022). Cognitive behavioral therapy for anxiety and related disorders: A meta-analysis of randomized placebo-controlled trials. Depression and Anxiety, 35(6), 502-514.
Craske, M. G., & Stein, M. B. (2021). Anxiety disorders. The Lancet, 397(10277), 914-927.
Hammond, D. C. (2020). Handbook of hypnotic suggestions and metaphors (2nd ed.). American Psychological Association.
Lebowitz, E. R., Shimshoni, Y., Silverman, W. K., & Marin, C. E. (2023). Family accommodation in pediatric anxiety disorders: Beyond OCD. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 87, 102580.
Mearns, D., & Thorne, B. (2022). Person-centred counselling in action (5th ed.). Sage Publications.
Stratton, P. (2019). The evidence base of family therapy and systemic practice. Association for Family Therapy and Systemic Practice.
Taylor, S., Landry, C. A., Paluszek, M. M., Fergus, T. A., McKay, D., & Asmundson, G. J. G. (2020). Development and initial validation of the COVID Stress Scales. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 72, 102232.
Watson, J. C., & Kalogivaki, N. (2020). Emotion-focused therapy for generalised anxiety disorder: An overview of the model. Person-Centered & Experiential Psychotherapies, 19(3), 265-283.
Yapko, M. D. (2018). Treating depression with hypnosis: Integrating cognitive-behavioral and strategic approaches. Routledge.
